Originally posted by sfphillyfan
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
This is (not) the only told-you-so thread I will ever start here...
Collapse
X
-
Originally posted by FRESH View PostMcNabb did look good, you hater. LOL!
Is it so hard to accept that the guy is/was a good QB?
I'm really getting sick of this crap where people can't stop comparing Kolb to McNabb. What's the point? He's gone, let's stop trying to justify it or pillory it.
Especially when there is a perfectly good argument -- Kolb or Vick?Don't kid yourself Jimmy. If a cow ever got the chance, he'd kill you and everyone you cared about!
Comment
-
Originally posted by Eagle60 View PostPliny. When teams win a super bowl, they PLAY OUT OF THEIR MINDS!!!!!!!!! Really, my only complaint about Kolb is that he reminds me of the little guy Pennington who had no arm. Smart player, but didn't have the tools. It's tough for DJ to light it up if the guy can't get it to him.
Kolb's downfield throws are tough to judge. We have been spoiled by having rocket arms like McNabb and Vick to compare Kolb to. If you compare Kolb to the other 30 QB's in the NFL, his arm strength would probably look just fine.
McNabb does not have Kolb's short-middle route accuracy. Kolb does not have McNabb's arm strength. Vick is playing super right now, but has not been accurate in the past.
I can't wait for Vick to get back. If he does not work out, then I can't wait to see more from Kolb.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Pliny View PostKolb might end up being a Pennington. I just feel it is way to early to make that determination one way or another.
Kolb's downfield throws are tough to judge. We have been spoiled by having rocket arms like McNabb and Vick to compare Kolb to. If you compare Kolb to the other 30 QB's in the NFL, his arm strength would probably look just fine.
McNabb does not have Kolb's short-middle route accuracy. Kolb does not have McNabb's arm strength. Vick is playing super right now, but has not been accurate in the past.
I can't wait for Vick to get back. If he does not work out, then I can't wait to see more from Kolb."Hey Giants, who's your Daddy?"
Comment
-
Originally posted by Leonard Tose View PostI'm really getting sick of this crap where people can't stop comparing Kolb to McNabb. What's the point? He's gone, let's stop trying to justify it or pillory it.
Especially when there is a perfectly good argument -- Kolb or Vick?http://shop.cafepress.com/content/global/img/spacer.gifOK, let's try this again...
Comment
-
Originally posted by FRESH View PostDeal with it. The guy was here 11 years and had a lot of success, replaced by these QB's now on our roster. It's a worthy topic of discusion..and will be for a few years yet.
Yeah, but it confuses me! I just want to talk Kolb or Vick and then someone brings up McNabb and I get addled. I'm getting old.Don't kid yourself Jimmy. If a cow ever got the chance, he'd kill you and everyone you cared about!
Comment
-
LOL! You'll be OK.
I'm ready to move forward too. Unfortunately, I feel like even if we DO get our QB situation settled, there are so many other problems with this team, it just doesn't matter.http://shop.cafepress.com/content/global/img/spacer.gifOK, let's try this again...
Comment
-
Originally posted by Eagle60 View PostYou had better hope he's here next year. I know what you're getting at, but playmakers win super bowls. Celek is dropping half the stuff that comes his way this year.
I like DJ but i don't get the feeling he will be here.
But you're right about Celek. You want to be the man, you gotta make some of those catches he whiffed on yesterday.
Comment
-
Originally posted by sfphillyfan View PostI like DJ but i don't get the feeling he will be here.
But you're right about Celek. You want to be the man, you gotta make some of those catches he whiffed on yesterday."Hey Giants, who's your Daddy?"
Comment
-
E60 - our offensive line is a mess, our defensive line is a mess. our superstar in the making mlb can't cover TEs. our other lbs couldn't play for Alabama. I don't think there's a lombardi in our future with or without DJ.
(And I didn't even mention the horrendous qb situation or head coach.)
And we have weasels and ferrets in our FO.
This team depresses me.
Comment
-
Originally posted by sfphillyfan View PostE60 - our offensive line is a mess, our defensive line is a mess. our superstar in the making mlb can't cover TEs. our other lbs couldn't play for Alabama. I don't think there's a lombardi in our future with or without DJ.
(And I didn't even mention the horrendous qb situation or head coach.)
And we have weasels and ferrets in our FO.
This team depresses me."Hey Giants, who's your Daddy?"
Comment
-
-
Originally posted by Rossovich View PostIt was all McNabb's fault when the team did not come back while he was here. No excuses. Now his team comes back & he didn't have a thing to do with it. Now there are all sorts of excuses why he had nothing to do with it. I can't make this shit up.Eliminate distractions, create energy, fear nothing, and attack everything.
-Andy Reid
Comment
-
Originally posted by leifdawg View PostLOL, Kolb was a little bit better than average against arguably the worst team in the league.
Comment
Comment